The complete guide to choosing an engagement ring

An engagement ring is one of the few pieces of jewelry that is chosen to be worn every day, for the rest of a life. It marks a promise, and with a little luck it becomes an heirloom that someone will wear long after you. No wonder choosing one can feel like a big decision.

The good news is that it becomes much easier once you know what to look at. In this guide, we walk you through how to choose an engagement ring step by step. You’ll read about the most popular engagement ring styles, the difference between diamonds, lab-grown diamonds and gemstones, how to pick a setting that suits everyday life, and when a bespoke ring might be the right choice.

Where to start when choosing an engagement ring

Before you look at stones or settings, it helps to answer three simple questions.

  1. What is their style? Look at the jewelry they already wear. Someone who wears fine, simple pieces will probably feel most at home with a delicate ring. Someone who loves vintage finds or bolder jewelry might prefer something with more character. If you’re choosing the ring together, this is an easy conversation to start with.
  2. What does their day look like? An engagement ring is worn through work, sport, travel and everything in between. Hands that are busy all day benefit from a lower, more protective setting and a hard stone.
  3. What is your budget? There is no fixed rule for how much an engagement ring should cost. Decide on a range that feels comfortable, and then see what fits within it. The size of the stone, the type of stone and the amount of gold all influence the price.

Once you have a rough idea of these three, the rest of the choices fall into place much more easily.

Popular engagement ring styles explained

Engagement ring styles describe the overall design of the ring, such as how many stones it has and how they’re arranged. These are the ones you’ll come across most often.

  1. Solitaire. A single stone on a plain band. It’s the most classic engagement ring style, and it lets the stone speak for itself.
  2. Halo. A center stone surrounded by a ring of smaller stones. The halo makes the center stone look larger and adds extra sparkle.
  3. Three-stone. A center stone with a smaller stone on each side. It’s often said to represent the past, present and future.
  4. Toi et moi. Two stones side by side, often in different shapes or colors. A playful choice that has become popular again.
  5. Vintage-inspired. Rings with softer shapes, details in the gold and a nod to the jewelry of earlier generations. Many of our own designs are inspired by the rings our grannies wore.

Some styles also work beautifully as part of a stack, together with a wedding band later on. If you think you’ll want that, it’s worth checking that the wedding band can sit comfortably next to the engagement ring.

Diamond, lab-grown diamond or gemstone

The stone is often the first thing people notice, and you have more options than you might think.

A diamond is the traditional choice. It’s the hardest natural material on the Mohs scale, scoring a 10, which makes it very well suited to a ring that’s worn every day. The shape of the diamond also changes the look of the ring a lot, from a round brilliant to an oval, pear or emerald cut. Our page on diamond shapes helps you see the differences.

A lab-grown diamond has the same chemical, physical and optical properties as a mined diamond. The difference is where it comes from. It’s grown in a lab instead of mined from the earth, and it’s usually more affordable, so you can often choose a larger stone within the same budget. Read more about them on our page about lab-grown diamonds.

A gemstone gives an engagement ring color and a personal story. Sapphire and ruby are popular choices because they’re very hard, with a score of 9 on the Mohs scale. Softer stones such as opal, pearl or emerald need more care in a ring that’s worn every day. Not sure which stone suits you? Our guide to the best gemstones for rings and our blog on gemstone hardness explain the differences.

Choosing a setting and fit for everyday wear

The setting is the way the stone is held in the ring, and it matters for both the look and how well the stone is protected.

A prong setting holds the stone with small claws of gold. It lets in a lot of light, so the stone sparkles more, but the stone sits higher and is a little more exposed. A bezel setting surrounds the stone with a rim of gold. It’s one of the most secure settings there is, and it gives the ring a smooth, modern look. A ring with a lower setting is also less likely to catch on clothes or hair.

The gold matters too. At Studio Kroewe, every engagement ring is made from recycled 14k gold, in yellow gold only. 14k gold is strong enough for everyday wear and can still be polished, repaired or resized decades from now.

Then there’s the fit. A ring that’s too tight is uncomfortable, and one that’s too loose can slip off. If you’re choosing the ring together, have the finger measured properly. Our guide to measuring your ring size explains how. If the size turns out to be slightly off, most rings can be adjusted later, as we explain in our blog on how a ring is resized.

Ready-made or bespoke engagement ring

You can choose one of our existing engagement rings, or have one made especially for you.

A ring from our collection is a design that has been carefully thought through, from the proportions of the band to the way the stone is set. Because we make to order, it’s only made once you’ve ordered it. Once we’ve received your order, we pass the baton to one of our talented local goldsmiths. Give her around four weeks to work her magic, so if you’re planning a proposal on a specific date, make sure to order on time.

Have something in mind that you can’t find in our collection? Then we’d love to design a bespoke engagement ring together with you. You can even use gold from an old family ring through our recycle your gold service, so a piece of family history becomes part of the new ring.

Want to see our designs in person first? You’re always welcome to visit our studio.

In the end, the right engagement ring is the one that feels like it was always meant to be theirs.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most popular engagement ring style?

The solitaire is the most classic and widely chosen engagement ring style. A single stone on a plain band is timeless and easy to combine with a wedding band later. Halo and three-stone rings are popular alternatives for those who want a little more sparkle.

How much should I spend on an engagement ring?

There is no fixed rule. Choose a budget that feels comfortable for you, and look at what fits within it. A lab-grown diamond or a gemstone can be a good way to get a larger or more colorful stone within the same budget.

Which engagement ring setting is best for an active lifestyle?

A bezel setting is one of the most secure options, because a rim of gold surrounds and protects the stone. A low setting and a hard stone, such as a diamond or sapphire, also help a ring hold up well to everyday wear.

What if the engagement ring doesn’t fit?

In most cases, a goldsmith can resize the ring, depending on the design. Read more in our blog on how a ring is resized. 

Can I design my own engagement ring?

Yes. At Studio Kroewe, we create bespoke engagement rings together with you, from the first idea to the finished ring. You can also use your own gold, for example from an old family ring.

The complete guide to choosing an engagement ring - Studio Kroewe